A.5.35 Organizational
Independent review of information security
Structured attributes from ISO/IEC 27002:2022 — control type · CIA properties · cybersecurity concept · operational capability · security domain. What do these mean?
Mapped NIST 800-53 r5 controls (9)
Our reading (mostly llm_verified) of how this ISO control and each NIST 800-53 control relate. Not an ISO or NIST product.
Direction: ← other covers this;
→ this covers other (F/M/P = full / mostly /
partial). gov = governs / implements (a mandate, not coverage).
Aligned NIST CSF 2.0 outcomes (19)
NIST CSF 2.0 outcomes this ISO control aligns with — our analysis (mostly llm_verified).
Direction: ← other covers this;
→ this covers other (F/M/P = full / mostly /
partial). gov = governs / implements (a mandate, not coverage).
Why these map — rationale
- GV.OV-03domain mandateimplements — A.5.35's independent review of the ISMS directly operationalizes the evaluation and review of cybersecurity risk management performance that GV.OV-03 requires within the governance oversight domain
- ID.IM-01domain mandateimplements — A.5.35's independent reviews operationally deliver the evaluations whose outputs are required by ID.IM-01 to identify improvements; the link is within the improvement-from-evaluation domain but ID.IM-01 does not name independent review specifically.
Related weaknesses / CWE (3234)
Weakness classes this ISO control helps prevent or mitigate — our analysis (mostly llm_verified).
Direction: ← other covers this;
→ this covers other (F/M/P = full / mostly /
partial). gov = governs / implements (a mandate, not coverage).
Why these map — rationale
- CWE-250partialfinds — Independent scrutiny can identify processes or services still running with unnecessary privileges and drive their reduction before an attacker can abuse them.
- CWE-284partialfinds — Periodic independent assessment of whether documented security objectives and controls are actually implemented and effective can surface missing or bypassed access-control decisions before they are exploited.
- CWE-285partialfinds — Independent reviewers evaluate whether authorization logic matches policy, thereby reducing the window in which incorrect or missing authorization checks remain in production.
- CWE-862partialfinds — By requiring competent outsiders to verify that every function enforces the need-to-know principle, the control lowers the likelihood that missing authorization checks persist undetected.
Mitigated MITRE ATT&CK techniques (3246)
Adversary techniques (MITRE ATT&CK Enterprise) this ISO control helps mitigate; links open attack.mitre.org. Our analysis (mostly llm_verified).
Direction: ← other covers this;
→ this covers other (F/M/P = full / mostly /
partial). gov = governs / implements (a mandate, not coverage).
Prevented OWASP Web Top 10 (2025) risks (11)
OWASP Web Top 10 (2025) risk categories this ISO control helps prevent or mitigate — our analysis (mostly llm_verified).
Direction: ← other covers this;
→ this covers other (F/M/P = full / mostly /
partial). gov = governs / implements (a mandate, not coverage).
Why these map — rationale
- A02partialfinds — independent reviews of the ISMS (including policies, controls and their implementation) can surface misconfigurations and weak defaults as part of assessing effectiveness and compliance, but the clause is a high-level governance review rather than targeted configuration scanning or testing, leaving the bulk of concrete misconfigurations untouched
- A06partialfinds — independent reviews of the ISMS (including policies, controls and opportunities for improvement) can surface design-level weaknesses when they manifest as inadequate or non-compliant controls, but the clause is a high-level governance process that does not systematically inspect architecture or designs for baked-in flaws
- A10partialfinds — independent reviews of the ISMS (including when triggered by incidents or significant changes) can surface mishandled error paths that violate policy or effectiveness criteria, but this is a minority slice of the class whose dominant members are code-level defects discovered by testing or static analysis
Control IDs, short titles and the structured attribute table (control type, CIA properties, cybersecurity-concept, operational capability, security domain) are facts from ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A / ISO/IEC 27002:2022. The full implementation guidance prose lives in ISO/IEC 27002:2022 — not reproduced here. Cross-walks to NIST 800-53, NIST CSF 2.0, OWASP ASVS, CWE, MITRE ATT&CK and OWASP Web Top 10 are our own analysis (mostly llm_verified), not an ISO, NIST, MITRE or OWASP product — how ours compare.